← Back Published on

4th and Oh is That Tom Brady, never mind First Down

Tom Brady winning another game against a divisional rival doesn’t sound like that big of a headline. NFL fans are keenly aware of what Tom Brady has done in the past to earn the title of the GOAT.

7 Lombardi Trophies

5 Super Bowl MVPs

3 League MVPs

15 Pro Bowl Selections

Even heading into season 23 at 45 years old, Brady still ranked as the No.1 amongst his peers in the NFL.

The fourth time Brady has managed to top this list and the first time a player of the age of 45 has ever done so.

From players to fans to analysts, everyone is aware of Brady’s legendary status. There’s no doubt that when HE finally decides to retire, there will be a golden jacket waiting for him in Canton, Ohio.

Yet it is that same level of greatness that has threatened the legitimacy of the sport at times.

After blowing a 21-point lead, Tom Brady and the Buccaneers found themselves in a bit of a jam on Sunday afternoon.

Late in the fourth quarter, on 3rd-and-5, leading Atlanta by just 6 points, Falcons defensive tackle Grady Jarrett sacked Tom Brady for a loss of 10 yards.

Or at least, that’s what NFL viewers thought Jarrett did until a penalty flag was thrown.

The hit on Brady was declared as roughing the passer, giving the Bucs an additional 15 yards and an automatic first down.

This caused quite the commotion on social media as fans and media personnel alike took to Twitter to voice their displeasure with the ruling on the field.

This penalty not only extended Tampa Bay’s drive but it also ruined any chance Atlanta had at winning the football. After the penalty, Brady was able to seal the game for Tampa Bay by running the clock out.

He connected with wide receiver Mike Evans on a 9-yard pass play just before the two-minute warning, the Falcons were all out of time outs, which allowed the Buccaneers to take a knee and put the game to rest.

After the game, referee Jerome Boger who has over 18 years of experience was asked for clarification on the controversial penalty.

“What I had was the defender grabbed the quarterback while he was still in the pocket, and unnecessarily throwing him to the ground,” Boger responded. “That is what I was making my decision based upon.”

Buccaneers head coach, Todd Bowles spoke on the matter as well during a post-game conference, as he believed that the situation mirrored what happened to Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa in Week 4.

Bowles is under the assumption that anytime a quarterback is “slung” to the ground, it will be flagged.

Even with all of the post-game explanation, fans were still enraged about the decision.

I cannot blame spectators for being upset with the ruling on the field. There’s been too many times where Brady has been the beneficiary of costly penalties.

Just recently, in his documentary “Man in the Arena”, he talked briefly about the “tuck rule”, and how if the call hadn’t gone his way, then his career would’ve slightly been a bit different.

Of course, if you are not aware of the tuck rule and how controversial it is, allow me to explain.

According to the NFL’s rule book, the official ruling is defined as:

“When [an offensive] player is holding the ball to pass it forward, any intentional forward movement of his arm starts a forward pass, even if the player loses possession of the ball as he is attempting to tuck it back toward his body. Also, if the player has tucked the ball into his body and then loses possession, it is a fumble.”

That means that any potential fumble could be ruled as an incomplete pass and referee are supposed to be the ones to determine whether or not a quarterback has made an intentional forward motion with their arms.

The ruling allotted more leeway to quarterbacks while simultaneously making it difficult for referees to officiate.

That was evident on a snowy day at Foxboro Stadium in an AFC divisional showdown between the Patriots and the Raiders.

During the game, one play and referee ruling made one of the most controversial calls in recent NFL history: The Tuck Rule play.

tuck-rule.jpg

On the blitz, Raiders defensive back Charles Woodson tackled Brady, causing the ball to land on the field and allowing Oakland linebacker Greg Biekert to recover the football. Many viewers thought it was a fumble, which would have sealed the game for the Raiders.

The officials huddled together to discuss the play and after the review, it was determined that Brady’s arms were in a throwing motion and attempted to “tuck” the ball towards his body, therefore making it an incomplete pass and resulting in the Patriots keeping the ball.

Thus, handing a young Tom Brady the ball back as he advanced it into field goal range. Adam Vinatieri kicks the 45-yard field goal, sends the game into overtime, and ultimately wins against the Raiders.

The Patriots went on to win the Super Bowl that year and started the birth of the New England dynasty as it gave Brady the first of his seven Super Bowl rings.

Still after 20 years, the game and the call has been debated. In May, Brady took to Twitter to troll NFL fans about the controversial calling as he admitted that it might’ve been a fumble.

Now I understand that Brady doesn’t make the rules as he clearly stated in his post-game press conference but at some point, he should recognize that he is considerably the favorite amongst players and teams who step out on the field against him.

The game between Atlanta and the Buccaneers wasn’t on the same caliber as a divisional playoff matchup, I still believe it will be remembered during this 2022-2023 season. Especially if it comes down to a playoff spot for the Falcons.

And who knows maybe twenty years later, Brady might admit the referees actually got it wrong but for now he has work to do as the Buccaneers are 3-2 on the season, leading the NFC South with an upcoming matchup against the struggling Pittsburgh Steelers in Week 6.